During the 2025 Indiana State Police Annual Awards Ceremony, Superintendent Anthony Scott presented a Commendation Award to Lieutenant Jerry Holeman in recognition of his extraordinary leadership throughout the multi-year investigation into the Delphi double homicide.
Lt. Holeman served as a primary investigative lead in the case surrounding the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German—an effort that spanned nearly eight years and demanded extensive coordination between law enforcement agencies at the local, state, and federal levels. His ability to manage teams, adapt to emerging developments, and remain focused under the scrutiny of national media coverage was essential in maintaining the investigation’s momentum and integrity.
The case produced tens of thousands of tips and an immense volume of digital and physical evidence. Lt. Holeman worked tirelessly to ensure all avenues were explored while also fostering collaboration across jurisdictions. His clear-headed leadership helped guide the team through many challenges.
This commendation honors Lt. Holeman’s unwavering dedication, resilience, and steady command presence, which brought credit to himself and the Indiana State Police throughout one of the most demanding investigations in the agency’s history.